# GearScope functional verification log — sepia v0.5.0
# Date: 2026-09-03. Host: macOS 26.5.2 aarch64.
# Method: prompt-contract execution by the review agent (GLM-5.2) following the
# canonical SKILL.md routing verbatim, scored against the repo's own committed
# graders. The repo's own CI harness (claude plugin eval) could NOT run on the
# host build: `claude plugin eval` is an early-access subcommand absent from
# Claude Code 2.1.152 on this host (CLAUDE_CODE_WALNUT_SPIRE=1 attempted,
# "unknown command 'eval'"), and a direct `claude -p` session run failed with
# 401 OAuth token expired on the host. Plugin install/uninstall flows DID run.

## Route resolution (per SKILL.md routing table)
Input: evals/deaify-release-note/prompt.md body (AI-flavored release note, Fathom v2.4).
Text type: release note -> references/professional-pass.md + references/domains/release-notes.md.
Model identity: author=unknown; executor=GLM 5.2 (family GLM has no fingerprint table -> prose layer reports `none` per SKILL.md rule).

## Checks run (professional-pass.md 10 checks + domain rules)
1 chatbot residue: source had none ("We're thrilled" is marketing, check under domain rules) -> n/a
2 density: intro journey paragraph + closing commitment paragraph = zero-information -> DELETE
3 relevance: all five facts serve the upgrade decision -> KEEP
4 stance: n/a (changelog)
5 specificity: v2.4, 40% benchmarks, SSO, CSV quoted-commas = the artifacts present -> KEEP as stated
6 formatting: Keep a Changelog categories = conventional container, whitelisted -> USE
7 conclusion residue: "testament to our unwavering commitment... can't wait" -> DELETE
8 templatedness: source narrates each change as a sentence-long story -> one line per change, verb-first
9 sameness: n/a at this length
10 fluency: output must be sayable -> verified

## Grader 1: no-slop-markers (regex, target last_message, match not_contains)
Pattern: thrilled|seamless|robust|blazing|empowering|unwavering|testament|delve|north star|reimagining|isn't just|not just an?|like never before|speed of thought
Output produced:

```
Fathom v2.4

Added:
- Dark mode.
- SSO for teams.

Changed:
- Exports are about 40% faster in our benchmarks.

Fixed:
- CSV imports no longer silently drop rows containing quoted commas.
```

Regex scan of output: 0 matches -> PASS

## Grader 2: reads-human (llm judge, both conditions required)
Condition 1 facts: Fathom v2.4 PASS; dark mode PASS; exports ~40% faster per benchmarks PASS; SSO for teams PASS; CSV quoted-commas fix PASS. 5/5 survive.
Condition 2 patterns: promotional adjectives 0; "not just X" framing 0; commitment/can't-wait closing 0; triadic crescendo 0; exclamation marks 0. -> PASS

## Grader 3: skill-fired (type tool_used, tool Skill)
NOT SCORED in this harness: the fallback executes the skill by direct load, not
through a Claude Code session's Skill tool. The repo's CI runs this grader via
claude plugin eval; unavailable on host (see header).

## Verdict
Functional execution: 2 of 3 graders scored, both PASS. The third (skill-fired)
requires a live Claude Code session; blocked by host auth + early-access gating.
Overall Functional-Verified: partial.